Skip to product information
1 of 3

Butterscotch Beer Jelly - just like that famous drink the witches and wizards love!

Regular price $6.99 USD
Regular price Sale price $6.99 USD
Sale Sold out
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Due to it's overwhelming popularity, we are currently sold out of Butterbeer Jelly, but are accepting preorders to ship out by the the end of November! Please order these separately from any other items, so it does not delay shipment of other items. Thanks!

Did you know that Wizard School inspired jelly exists? They do, and they're amazing!


Butterscotch Beer Jelly has all of the scrumptious flavors you'd expect from the drink; butterscotch, warm butter flavors, brown sugar and undertones of vanilla. I want to spoon this over ice cream or put it inside a layer cake, it's that good! This is a deep, rootbeer-brown colored jelly.


Completely handmade in artisanal small batches, I start each jelly with simple ingredients, and handcraft every batch. Each glass jar is then carefully filled and waterbath-canned according to US national guidelines to sterilize the glass jar and ensure the jelly remains shelf-stable until it's time to open and enjoy! Our smooth jelly is lump-free, and naturally GLUTEN-FREE too! Each jar has a colorful lid-topping label, and an ingredient label on the back. (Jar patterning and lid/ring color will vary slightly.)

Choose between a sampler jar (4 oz/118mL), or a half-pint jelly jar (8 oz/236mL) of our exciting HP themed jellies. Each will be carefully wrapped and shipped to you to enjoy! These make a lovely addition to a meal shared with family and friends, or a thoughtful (and tasty!) birthday, housewarming, or wedding gift for any fan of the series! (Please note: unless you are a witch or wizard and can cast cooling charms on your jars, please place jelly jar in the refrigerator once opened to ensure freshness. Best if opened within 8 months, and enjoyed within 3 months of opening!) These jellies are great on toast, cornbread, as a filling in cake layers or cupcakes, even by the spoonful or as an ice cream topping!

And now for the ingredients..

My Butterscotch Beer Jelly contains organic apple juice, sugar, brown sugar, fruit pectin (dextrose, sugar, fruit pectin, fumaric acid), vanilla extract (vanilla bean extractives in water, alcohol), butter extract (water, alcohol, natural flavors, extractive of butter [milk]), and butterscotch flavoring (water, propylene glycol, artificial flavor).

Now contains no artificial colors! 

Please also check out our other jam and jelly listings, which include Jelly Bean Jelly, Brown Frog Jelly, Pumpkin Juice Jelly, Pineapple jam and Pineapple Upside Down Cake jam, Peach Bellini jelly, Pink Moscato jelly, Lilac jelly, Wild Violet jelly, Red Bud jelly, Strawberry jam, Strawberry Rhubarb, Jalapeno Jelly and more!

At this point, we can only ship this item within the US.
Ordering multiple jams/jellies? I'll use the best shipping option for you, since auto-generated shipping costs are often not very accurate